In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court of India has ruled that domicile based reservations in postgraduate (PG) medical courses violate Article 14 of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to equality. This ruling significantly impacts state reservation policies, emphasizing that merit should be the sole criterion for admissions to PG medical programs.
Key Takeaways from the Supreme Court Verdict
• Domicile based reservation is Unconstitutional – The Court declared that using domicile as a criterion for admission in PG medical courses is discriminatory and violates the principles of equality.
• Domicile Quota Permitted Only in MBBS Admissions – The ruling clarifies that state-based reservations can be applied only at the MBBS level, not in PG medical admissions.
•State Quota Seats to Be Filled on Merit – The judgment mandates that seats reserved for state quota in PG medical courses must be allocated purely based on merit in the NEET-PG examination, similar to the All India Quota (AIQ) system.
• Judgment Will Be Applicable from the Next Academic Session – Ongoing admissions and counseling processes for NEET-PG 2024 will not be affected. The ruling will come into effect from the next academic session (NEET-PG 2025).
Impact of the Verdict
Strengthening Merit-Based Admissions
This judgment reinforces the Supreme Court’s stance that merit should be the primary factor in medical education admissions. It prevents states from prioritizing local candidates over more qualified applicants from other regions, thereby ensuring that the best candidates secure PG seats.
Uniform Admission Criteria Across India
With this ruling, PG medical admissions across India will follow a standardized approach, similar to AIQ admissions, reducing state-wise variations in selection criteria.
Increased Competition for PG Medical Seats
Since domicile based reservations are removed, candidates from all over India will now compete for PG seats in every state, increasing competition and potentially benefiting students with higher ranks in NEET-PG.
Potential Challenges for State Governments
Many states had implemented domicile based reservation in PG medical admissions to retain doctors within their state healthcare system. With this decision, states might need to explore alternative strategies, such as bond systems, to ensure medical professionals serve in their respective states after completing PG courses.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s decision marks a significant shift in India’s medical education system. By upholding meritocracy and striking down domicile based reservations in PG admissions, the ruling ensures a more competitive and fair selection process for future specialists.
As the medical community and aspirants prepare for NEET-PG 2025 under the new rules, it remains to be seen how states will adapt to this policy change. Stay tuned for further updates on this crucial development.
For more updates on , follow us on X (Twitter), Instagram & Facebook. And our website MED COLLEGE DARSHAN.
