India’s healthcare system is vast, complex, and deeply reliant on its medical professionals. Yet, when it comes to leadership roles in medical institutions—such as Dean, Principal, or Medical Superintendent—a glaring contradiction persists. Young doctors, despite their rich clinical, academic, and research backgrounds, find themselves locked out of these influential positions due to rigid eligibility criteria based on age and years of teaching experience. Meanwhile, IAS officers, often in their late 20s or early 30s, are entrusted with the administration of entire districts, ministries, and nationwide programs.
This raises a fundamental question:
Why can’t a doctor in their 30s with vision, integrity, and experience lead a medical college or hospital, just as their IAS counterpart manages entire districts?
The Systemic Disparity
The crux of this issue lies in institutional norms governed by the National Medical Commission (NMC), previously the Medical Council of India (MCI). To be eligible for senior administrative roles in medical institutions, a doctor must have 10–20 years of teaching experience post-specialization. This rule is well-intentioned—to ensure experience and maturity—but it often excludes passionate, reform-minded doctors who are capable of transformative leadership in their 30s and early 40s.
In contrast, an IAS officer undergoes a 2-year training program at institutions like LBSNAA (Lal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration), post which they immediately assume positions of power—first as Sub-Divisional Magistrates (SDMs) and later as District Magistrates (DMs), Secretaries, and Commissioners. Their training and system encourage leadership, decision-making, and innovation from the outset.
Why the Gap Exists
- Regulatory Rigidity:
NMC rules are built around seniority and teaching experience rather than leadership potential or innovation. It is assumed that good clinicians or researchers must wait decades to lead. - Lack of a Leadership Pipeline:
Medicine in India offers no structured administrative training like the civil services. There’s no equivalent of LBSNAA for doctors—no space that grooms them in public health leadership, hospital management, or policy-making. - Politicization and Patronage:
Leadership in medical colleges often becomes a game of allegiance. Instead of merit or vision, political loyalty or internal power plays determine who becomes the head, further discouraging young, capable doctors.
What Needs to Change
- Create a Healthcare Leadership Cadre:
Like the IAS or IPS, we need a dedicated cadre for healthcare leadership—one that identifies, grooms, and deploys doctors into roles that shape health policy, medical education, and hospital management. - Revise NMC Norms:
The NMC must consider relaxing the minimum experience barrier for doctors with proven academic achievements, leadership qualities, and management training. A fast-track eligibility path should be carved for such professionals. - Introduce Structured Leadership Training:
Institutions like AIIMS, IIMs, or PHFI (Public Health Foundation of India) should run specialized courses in medical administration, public health governance, and policy. These programs can be fast-tracked for doctors who show an aptitude for leadership, much like executive MBAs or IAS training.
Why It Matters
The need for visionary, ethical, and young leaders in Indian medical institutions has never been more urgent. With rising challenges—burnout, brain drain, violence against doctors, and collapsing medical infrastructure—our system cannot afford to wait for change to trickle in over decades.
Younger leaders bring fresh ideas, energy, adaptability, and a keener understanding of modern medical realities. Denying them leadership is a loss not just for the individual but for the healthcare system as a whole.
Conclusion
Leadership is not about age—it is about ability, vision, and intent. Just as IAS officers are trusted with national development early in their careers, young doctors must be trusted to shape the future of Indian healthcare.
It’s time we broke the age-old chains of seniority and gave merit, passion, and potential their rightful place at the top. Let the stethoscope also lead, not just serve.
This article presents the thought-provoking idea of Dr. T. K. Beniwal, advocating for leadership opportunities for young doctors in medical administration and challenging the age-based barriers that restrict their potential to bring transformative change.
For more updates, follow us on X (Twitter), Instagram & Facebook. And our website MED COLLEGE DARSHAN.
