R.G. Kar Medical College, Kolkata, August 2024 – In the aftermath of the horrifying rape and murder of a postgraduate doctor at R.G. Kar Medical College, the medical community across India expected decisive action. Yet, both the central and state governments have cleverly sidestepped responsibility, maintaining a strategic silence. This has left healthcare professionals frustrated and vulnerable, with no progress on the long-demanded Central Protection Act and no justice in sight for the victim of R.G. Kar.
The Central Government’s Tactical Escape on the Central Protection Act
For years, healthcare professionals have been advocating for a Central Protection Act, a law that would safeguard doctors and healthcare workers against the rising incidents of violence and assault. This demand intensified following the R.G. Kar tragedy, as nationwide protests erupted, with doctors shutting down services and marching in solidarity. The medical fraternity made it clear that enough was enough – they demanded protection.
However, the central government has managed to escape any real accountability on this issue. Instead of engaging with the demands, it has remained conspicuously silent. While minor assurances were made behind closed doors, there has been no concrete move to push the Central Protection Act through parliament. The government’s silence, while protests raged across the country, spoke louder than words.
Despite repeated requests from major medical bodies such as the Indian Medical Association (IMA) and Federation of Resident Doctors Association (FORDA), UDFA the issue remains unresolved. Instead of addressing the root cause of doctors’ safety, the central government has shifted its focus to other issues, effectively dodging the question of healthcare safety reforms. This calculated inaction has left doctors exposed to increasing threats without any national legal protection.
The West Bengal Government’s Evasion on the R.G. Kar Case
On the other hand, the state government of West Bengal has demonstrated a similar reluctance to take responsibility for the horrific crime at R.G. Kar Medical College. While protests raged, and the medical community demanded swift justice, the state government failed to act decisively. The law and order situation in West Bengal has come under severe scrutiny, with many accusing the ruling party of failing to maintain safety and security, especially for vulnerable communities like healthcare workers.
The investigation into the R.G. Kar case has been marred by delays, evasion, and a lack of transparency. Dr. Sandip Ghosh, the former principal of R.G. Kar Medical College, who has been accused of corruption and unethical practices, continues to be a central figure in the case. Yet, despite growing suspicions about his involvement in the crime, the state government has remained mostly silent, neither confirming nor denying the allegations. This lack of action and accountability has raised concerns about possible interference in the investigation.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) was eventually brought into the case after widespread public outrage, but many believe this was only done to placate protesters rather than out of a genuine desire for justice. The state government’s silence on the matter has only deepened the distrust between healthcare professionals and the authorities.
Law and Order in West Bengal: A Growing Concern
The R.G. Kar case is not an isolated incident. In recent years, West Bengal has seen a series of violence after election, attacks on political party workers, attacks against doctors, healthcare workers, and other professionals. Despite these alarming trends, the state government has failed to implement effective measures to improve the law and order situation. Instead, it has deflected responsibility, often blaming opposition parties or external forces for the unrest.
In the case of R.G. Kar, the attacks on protesting doctors and efforts to obstruct the investigation have further exacerbated the situation. Doctors who took to the streets, demanding justice and protection, found themselves under attack by violent mobs. The state’s inability or unwillingness to protect these protesters has raised serious concerns about the safety of doctors working in West Bengal.
The Bigger Picture: Systemic Failure
Both the central and state governments’ responses—or lack thereof—highlight a larger, systemic failure to address the real concerns of healthcare professionals. The central government’s refusal to prioritize the Central Protection Act, despite pan-India protests, and the state government’s mishandling of the R.G. Kar case reflect a disturbing pattern of indifference toward those who save lives.
The silence from both sides is indicative of a broader issue: healthcare professionals in India, despite their critical role, are often treated as expendable. The repeated assurances that reforms will come are nothing more than empty promises if the government continues to evade actual action. The medical community deserves more than hollow words. They need legal protection, a safer working environment, and, in the case of R.G. Kar, justice for the victim.
Conclusion: Doctors Left Abandoned
The silence from both the central and state governments in response to these crucial issues is telling. It reveals a strategy of evasion, where those in power quietly avoid the tough decisions, leaving vulnerable groups like doctors to fend for themselves. The central government’s inaction on the Central Protection Act, combined with the West Bengal government’s failure to deliver justice in the R.G. Kar case, leaves doctors across the country feeling abandoned, angry, and betrayed.
As the protests continue, the question remains: how much longer will the authorities remain silent, and at what cost to those who dedicate their lives to saving others?
For more live updates, follow us on X (Twitter), Instagram & Facebook. And our website MED COLLEGE DARSHAN.
