18 June 2024, NEET SC Hearing :
The Supreme Court of India emphasized the need for absolute precision in the conduct of the NEET-UG 2024 exams, urging the Union Government and the National Testing Agency (NTA) to address even the slightest negligence with utmost seriousness. The vacation bench, comprising Justices Vikram Nath and S.V. Bhatti, made these remarks while hearing a writ petition that raised issues similar to those in previous cases, such as paper leaks, malpractices, and the controversial awarding of grace marks to some candidates.
Strict Action for Even Minimal Negligence
Justice Bhatti underscored the necessity of addressing any errors, however minor, stating, “Even if there is 0.001% negligence on the part of anyone, it should be thoroughly dealt with.” said during NEET SC Hearing. He stressed that the integrity of the examination process is crucial, given the significant effort candidates invest in preparing for this highly competitive test. Justice Bhatti also noted the potential societal dangers posed by individuals who might become doctors through fraudulent means.
Call for Proactive Measures
During the NEET SC Hearing, the bench called on the NTA and the Union Government to act proactively and transparently. Justice Bhatti remarked, “If there is a mistake, yes there is a mistake, this is the action we will take- at least that inspires confidence in your performance.” He pointed out that such an approach would help restore public trust in the NEET examinations.
The justices emphasized that the matter should not be treated as adversarial litigation, highlighting the importance of cooperation and accountability in resolving the issues at hand.
Concerns Over Investigation Status
While NEET SC Hearing, the petitioners raised concerns about the status of the investigation into the NEET-UG paper leak cases, noting the impending counselling session scheduled for July 6. They argued that timely updates on the investigation were crucial for the candidates’ future prospects.
In response, the bench tagged the current petition with other pending cases and directed the NTA and the Union to submit their responses within two weeks. The court scheduled a detailed hearing for July 8, where all related submissions would be considered.
Firm Stance on Negligence
Justice Bhatti highlighted the importance of dealing with any errors, however minor, stating, “Even if there is 0.001% negligence on the part of anyone, it should be thoroughly dealt with.” He emphasized the critical role of maintaining the examination’s integrity, given the extensive effort candidates invest in preparing for this competitive test. Justice Bhatti also noted the societal risks associated with individuals who might become doctors through fraudulent means, asserting during the NEET SC Hearing, “A candidate who becomes a doctor after playing fraud in the exam is more dangerous to society.”
Proactive and Transparent Measures
During the NEET SC Hearing, The bench urged the NTA and the Union Government to adopt a proactive and transparent approach. Justice Bhatti remarked, “If there is a mistake, yes there is a mistake, this is the action we will take – at least that inspires confidence in your performance.” He pointed out that such an approach would help restore public trust in the NEET examinations. Justice Bhatti further emphasized the importance of not treating the matter as adversarial litigation but rather as a cooperative effort to resolve the issues.
Advocate Kanu Agrawal and Vardhaman Kaushik, representing the Union Government and the NTA respectively, were present at the hearing. Justice Bhatti stressed the need for the NTA to act proactively and admit any mistakes, stating, “Your stance ought not to change the moment you enter the court, representing the Agency responsible for conducting the examination.” He emphasized the importance of admitting mistakes and taking corrective actions to maintain public confidence in the examination system.
For more live updates on NEET SC Hearing, follow us on X (Twitter), Instagram & Facebook. And our website MED COLLEGE DARSHAN.
